2023-24 ST. JOE'S COLLEGIATE MAROON
2022-23 ST. FRANCIS PREP
2021-22 WILLIAMSVILLE NORTH
2020-21 ST. FRANCIS PREP
2019-20 ST. FRANCIS PREP
2018-19 CANISIUS BLUE
2017-18 WILLIAMSVILLE NORTH
2016-17 WILLIAMSVILLE NORTH
2015-16 WILLIAMSVILLE NORTH
2014-15 WILLIAMSVILLE NORTH
2013-14 ST. JOE'S COLLEGIATE MAROON
2012-13 CANISIUS BLUE
2011-12 ST. JOE'S COLLEGIATE MAROON
2010-11 WILLIAMSVILLE NORTH
2009-10 CLARENCE
2008-09 CANISIUS BLUE
2007-08 BISHOP TIMON/ST. JUDE
2006-07 KENMORE EAST
2005-06 WILLIAMSVILLE NORTH
2004-05 WILLIAMSVILLE NORTH
2003-04 WILLIAMSVILLE NORTH
2002-03 WILLIAMSVILLE NORTH
2001-02 ST. JOE'S COLLEGIATE MAROON
2000-01 ST. JOE'S COLLEGIATE MAROON
2022-23 WILLIAMSVILLE EAST
2021-22 CLARENCE
2020-21 CANISIUS GOLD
2019-20 FRONTIER